Insights
The Hidden Cost of Decision Loops: Why Coaching Helps Leaders Move Forward
By Mimi Moore, CEO Pourquoi Pas Coaching International
Decision loops lead to decision paralysis – hence the importance of knowing how to get out of them sooner rather than later.
For the last couple of weeks, I have been sitting on a simple decision: that of assigning a file to one of my coaches. And then it struck me, I am stuck in my own decision loop.
Ironically, I see this in some of my coaching clients. It's tough on them (and their people), but the good news is, they can come out of them!
Let me ask this: have you ever found yourself revisiting the same decision over and over again?
You gather more information. You ask one more person. You play out every possible scenario. You tell yourself you'll decide tomorrow.
Tomorrow becomes next week.
From the outside, it can look like procrastination.
But for many leaders, it isn't. It's something far more subtle: it's a decision loop. Decision loops happen when thinking replaces deciding. Instead of moving toward action, we continue searching for certainty that simply doesn't exist.
Believe it or not, this can also affect the very people who are known for making difficult decisions every day.
Senior leaders are accustomed to weighing competing priorities, managing risk, and considering the impact of every choice. Those are valuable leadership skills. Yet those same strengths can become liabilities when every decision feels as though it must be perfect before it can be made.
The result?
Progress slows.
Confidence erodes.
Mental energy is consumed by a decision that never seems to reach the finish line. And when it finally does reach the finish line, it feels like a tough slog.
Research consistently shows that procrastination is less about poor time management than about emotional regulation. Fear of making the wrong choice, perfectionism, uncertainty, and the discomfort of ambiguity often keep us stuck far more than a lack of discipline does.
In coaching, we rarely begin by asking, "Why haven't you done it?"
Instead, we ask different questions such as:
- What makes this decision difficult?
- What assumptions are driving your hesitation?
- What small, first step can you take to get out of the loop?
Often, the issue isn't the decision itself.
It's the story surrounding it.
"I need more information."
"What if I get it wrong or worse, disappoint someone?"
"I've got lots of time, maybe the answer will become obvious."
The longer we remain in that loop, the heavier the decision becomes.
I've seen leaders postpone organizational changes, delay difficult conversations, hold back on career opportunities, and hesitate to delegate – not because they lacked capability, but because they were searching for certainty.
Coaching doesn't remove uncertainty. It helps leaders become more comfortable leading through it.
A good coach creates space to slow the thinking without slowing the momentum. They challenge assumptions, uncover blind spots, and help leaders distinguish between thoughtful analysis and unproductive rumination.
One question I often ask clients is surprisingly simple:
"What decision have you already made that you simply haven't acted on?"
The answer usually comes quickly. Deep down, many leaders already know the direction they want to take. It's about identifying and taking that first small step in the right direction.
More often than not, that's all it takes: a first small step.
Overtime, this enables leaders to trust their own judgment. Because the most effective leaders don't eliminate uncertainty. They eliminate unnecessary delay. Because every decision consumes energy until it's made.
The greatest value of coaching isn't helping someone find the answer. It's helping them stop asking the same question.
The shift is profound, and the burden that's lifted isn't just the decision itself – it's the mental energy spent in the circular and endless decision loop.
And then, there is clarity and calmness manifested in different ways and various forms.
In case you're wondering, I assigned the file last night and got out of my own loop by simply identifying and taking that first small step!
Know anyone who could benefit from coaching? Send them our way or write to us at [email protected]
Learn more about Pourquoi Pas and its suite of services at www.pqpci.com
Originally published on LinkedIn on .